McKinley: Collaboration key to National Guard relationships

Photo By Master Sgt. Jim Greenhill | The attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, and Hurricane Katrina resulted in a relationship between the National Guard and other components of the armed forces where collaboration has replaced conflict, Gen. Craig McKinley, the chief of the National Guard Bureau, told the National Homeland Defense Foundation Symposium meeting in Colorado Springs, Colo., Nov. 9, 2009.  

COLORADO SPRINGS, UNITED STATES

11.12.2009

Story by Staff Sgt. Jim Greenhill 

National Guard Bureau

COLORADO SPRINGS, Colo. - Conflict might have been the 20th century norm, but collaboration is the nature of 21st century relationships between the National Guard and other components of the armed forces, the chief of the National Guard Bureau said here Monday.

"There have always been challenges between the active component forces and the National Guard simply from where we come from culturally," Air Force Gen. Craig McKinley told the National Homeland Defense Foundation Symposium. "But the events of Sept. 11, 2001, and Hurricane Katrina ... have brought us to a point where conflict no longer has a place. ...

"We've got to collaborate. ... The governors need a strong, viable, relevant National Guard to protect their citizens at home, and the Army and the Air Force need a strong National Guard that can help alleviate the tempo on the active duty force."

Leaders and policymakers will always debate the roles of the Guard and other components, McKinley said, but in a crisis, citizens care only about results.

"While those of us in D.C. and state capitols debate who's in charge, the men and women of the military - active, Guard and Reserve - focus on getting the job done and supporting the local officials who need help," McKinley said.

"The 'who's in charge game' seldom occurs on the ground where the work is really getting done. We see this over and over again with no-notice incidents and cold-start events - Guard, civilian, local, state and federal responders all work closely together to get the job done."

Nevertheless - with the Quadrennial Defense Review and a presidential budget review in preparation for the 2011 Program Objective Memorandum as background - there is a necessary debate about the Guard's exact role.

"This debate is passionate, and it's contentious, and there's good points to be made on both sides," McKinley said.

"We're debating two primary schools of thought. ... There's a primarily federal response to a disaster ... and then there's the state or the regional approach which, for 372 years, the National Guard has done well. It's a community-based force. It's dispersed. It's in the nation. It's out there every day and can be called upon when needed, and it's scalable to the disaster."

In about 95 percent of probable domestic disaster scenarios, the traditional National Guard response in support of civilian authorities works best, McKinley said.

"Community-based forces have a familiarity with the local culture," he said. "They understand the importance of locally elected officials."

Besides, as a city public safety leader recently told McKinley during a domestic response exercise, "All events begin locally and they end locally."

Said McKinley, "It's what happens in between ... that we in government have got to continue to focus on."

In a small number of scenarios, such as the use of a weapon of mass destruction in an American city, "The locals may be rapidly overwhelmed, and an aggressive federal response is needed," McKinley said. "This is going to take a whole-of-government solution."

Although the debate about the balance between federal and state leadership that started with the writing of the Constitution is likely to continue indefinitely, "We in the National Guard know that there must be unity of command, and the active component force knows that there must be unity of effort."

Regardless of exactly how specific policy debates are resolved, "The National Guard ... will form the core of any domestic response," McKinley said. "Active [duty] forces will be available to fill in the gaps and augment when needed. ... In the end, it's all about preserving the security and safety of our American way of life."

• Date Taken: 11.12.2009
• Date Posted: 11.12.2009 14:19
• Story ID: 41477
• Location: COLORADO SPRINGS, US